South Tucson council member-elect says he lives outside city

South Tucson City Council member-elect Eduardo Baca says he lives outside the city, and voters have until Nov. 22 to challenge his election.

South Tucson council member-elect says he lives outside city
A bilingual sign directs South Tucson voters to a polling place. Eduardo Baca won one of two open City Council seats in the Nov. 3 general election. Topacio "Topaz" Servellon / Tucson Spotlight.

Eduardo Baca won a seat on the South Tucson City Council this month, but he says he doesn’t live in the city.

City code and state law both require council members to live in the city for at least a year before an election and to stay there while in office. Baca said he sleeps at a home outside the city limits and spends most of his time at his South Tucson upholstery shop.

Any voter who wants to challenge his election has until Sunday, Nov. 22, to file a complaint in Pima County Superior Court.

At its Nov. 17 meeting, the council unanimously certified the results of the Nov. 3 general election, in which two seats were open. Baca received 353 votes and replaced incumbent Brian Flagg, who received 289.

Incumbent Cesar Aguirre, who was also up for reelection, maintained his council seat, receiving 388 votes.

Debbie Federico, Baca’s campaign partner for the general election, finished third with 345 votes, eight votes behind Baca.

Before the council adopted and certified the results, Moreno said the canvass arrived late the previous afternoon, delaying the installation of the newly elected officials, who are typically installed at the first council meeting after the election. They will be sworn in at the next council meeting on Dec. 5.

“In my experience of being the city clerk here with South Tucson since 2011, this is the highest (number of) votes I’ve ever seen on record,” City Manager Veronica Moreno said during the meeting, thanking Flagg for his service on the council.

Your membership pays emerging journalists to cover Southern Arizona the way it deserves.

Back the next byline
Eduardo Baca, who won a seat on the South Tucson City Council, owns Baca Upholstery. He says he spends most of his time at the business, not at home. Courtesy of Baca Upholstery.

Baca, who has owned an upholstery business in South Tucson since 1982 and sits on the city’s rezoning committee, said he felt nervous about joining the council but looks forward to serving.

“I was nervous for a bit of time, then I said, ‘Well, I’m in now . . . let’s see what comes of it,’” Baca said.

After he’s sworn into office, Baca plans to create a coalition of residents to keep the city clean by watching out for litter and weeds and keeping track of roads that may need maintenance.

But because Baca says he does not live in South Tucson, his seat on the council remains in question.

Section 2-38a of South Tucson’s city code says that “each candidate for elective office shall have been a resident of the city for at least one year immediately preceding their filing of nomination papers, and shall continue residence in the city while in office.”

Baca filed his Declaration of Qualification on March 19, listing his business address as his residential address.

But his business is not zoned for residential purposes.

Arizona Corporation Commission records separately list Baca as the manager of the business and give his residential address as a home on South San Joaquin Avenue in Tucson.

A campaign sign for Roxanna Valenzuela, Cesar Aguirre and Brian Flagg stands outside the South Tucson Municipal Complex. Aguirre kept his council seat in the Nov. 3 general election, while Eduardo Baca replaced Flagg. Topacio "Topaz" Servellon / Tucson Spotlight.

A Pima County parcel search lists Baca as an owner of the same property, and Pima County Treasurer’s Office real estate tax records name Baca as the taxpayer.

Baca said the listed residence is his home address, adding that most of his time is spent at his business, not at his home.

“You’ll find me here (at my business),” Baca said. “You’ll find me at home on Sundays. I have breakfast, lunch and dinner here (at my business), I’m here until 8 p.m. I only go there to sleep, like a hotel.”

He also said more than one other council member owns property in South Tucson but does not actually live there.

Moreno did not respond to a request for comment about the situation but pointed to state law, including A.R.S. 9-232A and A.R.S. 16-6748.

A.R.S. 9-232A says that a person “shall not be a member of a city or town council unless, at the time of the election (they’re) a qualified elector residing within the city or town and has resided in the city or town for at least one year next preceding the election.”

A.R.S. 16-6748 says any voter in an Arizona city may contest an office winner’s election by filing a complaint in county superior court.

But A.R.S. 16-673 says that a voter contesting a local election has five calendar days from the completion of the canvass, or the official vote count, to contest election results.


Topacio “Topaz” Servellon is a reporter with Tucson Spotlight. Contact them at topacioserve@gmail.com.

Tucson Spotlight is a community-based newsroom that provides paid opportunities for students and rising journalists in Southern Arizona. Please consider supporting our work with a tax-deductible donation.